What can you write about a movie that’s two hours too long and interminably boring? That it is verbose. That it tries too hard. And that it does have two or three moments. Finis.
One expected much more from Imtiaz Ali, even if it was pretty much par for the course for Saif. After Socha Na Tha and Jab We Met, the expectations were huge. Hell, after being terribly disappointed by both Ice Age 3 and Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen, I actually thought LAK would end the movie drought. Wishful thinking, as it turned out. It’s a film that tries too hard to be smart, too hard to be trendy, too hard to live up to its own hype.
The biggest takeaway is that there’s too much friggin’ talk in the film. Yap Yap Yap. Yackety Yak. Blah Blah Blah. Yada Yada Yada. And then more of the same. The interval came and I asked myself, “So what’s happened so far?” The answer was: Jai and Meera had just broken up. That’s it. The rest was all talk.
There is some kind of plot. Just barely. Boy meets girl, they hit it off, they carry on for some time, they break up, they discover that they’re still very fond of each other, and even though they each enter into a different relationship that doesn’t quite make the grade, they continue to be friends along the lines of Sally Albright and Harry Burns, and after a couple of predictable twists, they figure out they’re fated to be together.
It just doesn’t have enough meat for a two hour film. While even Jab We Met was thin on plot, it was high on moments. It was high on laughs. And the actors never overshadowed the characters, and the setting never overshadowed the film. But in this one – all that could go wrong, did.
There’s absolutely no chemistry between the lead pair. Zero. As for the actors themselves, I have never thought too highly of Saif and he did nothing to change my opinion. Deepika looked good, but her dialogue delivery was stilted. Luckily for her, most of the film seemed to be a lengthy monologue by Saif and so she didn’t get too many chances to show off her poor acting skills. But I must say that one of the three good moments in the film – for me – was a Deepika moment. More on that later. Rishi Kapoor was good.
I am not sure how the film will do. The theatre was packed, so that means it’ll probably do well. The audience laughed at all the wrong places, and that could also make the film the surprise comedy hit of the year. The music’s quite decent, and it has been well received. But given that it’s Pritam’s music, I figure one will not have to wait too long before the ‘inspiration’ behind these tunes comes to light.
For me, there were three good moments in the film. The best, by far, was when Veer Singh goes to Calcutta to ‘meet’ Harleen (extremely well-cast). A beautifully done moment, with no dialogues (phew!) and a very nice song in the background. Conveyed everything one wanted to know about the characters and their relationship.
The second was when a drunken Jai escorts a sloshed Meera to her apartment. As has been the case with all of us who have been that drunk, one always has the urge, at that point of time, to show the world one is normal. So I identified with Jai when he nonchalantly asked the watchman “Aur bhai, sab theek-thakk hai?” – or something along those lines.
The third moment – the Deepika moment – was when Jai finally seeks out Meera, and, while she pretends to be normal, casual even, she does quietly give in to her emotions for a brief moment – but when Jai can’t see her.
But three moments do not a film make, and therein lies the rub with Love Aaj Kal. As Meera says to Jai early on in the film – when he tries too hard to be hot, he doesn’t succeed.
Imtiaz should have listened to that bit of advice from his own script.
August 1, 2009 at 3:29 pm
Ahhh … looks like I have to skip this one as well … 😦
When is a decent movie coming our way ??? 😐
August 1, 2009 at 4:32 pm
Saif did all the talking? Yikes! His voice is horrible…I wonder how you sat through the movie…
August 1, 2009 at 4:44 pm
Though i didn’t find it this boring, i didn’t like it too much either! And i liked said more in “sardar” get up then in “today’s world” get up… probably found it too loud… dunno! Deepika was cool ( i mean hot! 😉 )
August 1, 2009 at 6:13 pm
Well, now that my expectations have been dashed to the ground, i will enjoy the film 😉
August 1, 2009 at 7:11 pm
This movie is getting mixed reviews!
August 1, 2009 at 8:00 pm
Why even to venture out to watch a movie which is called “Love Aaj Kal ” . The title is a cross over , the movie appears as a cross over of different romantic movies .
August 1, 2009 at 8:39 pm
Bad movie.
Deepika is nowhere near as effervescent as Kareena in JVM and Saif looks like a silly middle aged man trying to look cool doing the twist. His monologues sucked…BIGGG time.
Sad!
August 1, 2009 at 9:01 pm
Kya yaar..I have taken tickets for tomorrow..
Anyway it was my mistake…I will watch those three moments at least..
No one makes movie like Jab we met…it happens..by chance..even Imtiyaz can’t repeat that..
Cheers
Manish
August 2, 2009 at 1:09 pm
Yeah, I was thinking of going to watch it just because of JWM. Thankfully, you saved my cash. After Luck, this is another F***…
August 2, 2009 at 1:27 pm
You thrashed the movie, and Amit hailed it http://is.gd/1YK6L Now am confused whether to watch it or not =/
August 2, 2009 at 4:11 pm
boring? hmmm…a few other reviews found that the movie was long too. anyway, surely not worth $10 in a theatre for me. will catch some copy of the same on the net 😉
August 2, 2009 at 6:53 pm
I have not seen the film. But I am reminded of a film called ‘Three Times’. The silences and words are replaced by gizmos. And there is no real silence in relationships.
August 3, 2009 at 12:16 am
That bad? 😆 I am going to watch it anyways but whenever DVD comes out.
August 3, 2009 at 3:35 am
totally agree dude!!!!!!!
I also watched the film yesterday 😛 it is just not worth it 😛
August 3, 2009 at 10:45 am
And I cringed at the fayda(how do you spell it) moments. The whole phone convo pissed me off. The songs were good.Thats it. Nothing else.
August 3, 2009 at 11:20 am
I found it average. Good for one watch … but agree on the Saif monologues – too many and expressionless.
August 3, 2009 at 11:59 am
This is one review I totally agree with. I found the movie just about O.K. I am still surprised by the fact that it has received 4 star ratings!!!!
Whenever Deepika uttered a word I word turn back & say she can’t act and everyone around me would look back as if I have come from Mars. She looks good, taht is to it.
Saif!! huh!! there was this scene at the airport! Rishi Kapoor looked fresher than him!!!!
I even totally agree with the three scenes that u have picked, I felt the whole incident where “Saif comes to Delhi and meets Deepika and they have a helluva time” was the best sequence of the movie because it was then that the proceedings come to life after that it is just a lifeless story where nothing happens in the 1st half and too much happens in the 2nd half.
Jab We met is once in a life time movie so this can not be compared to that, but yes it falls short of even Socha Na Tha!!!
August 3, 2009 at 12:25 pm
Aw! QI, have to disagree on this one. I saw it yesterday and quite liked it for these reasons-
(1) although the dialogue delivery was bad, the movie had a story to tell, and it wasnt a run of the mill kind of kahani. Most would have ended when Saif meets Deepika on her wedding day( most movies would have ended with Saif or Deepika professing their love and then usual naach gaana, happy ending)
(2) the movie was very well edited, the transition from the new story to the old and back was quite in sync and didnt feel like a mess at all.
(3) a lot happened in those 2 hours…seriously …2 eras and a wedding, breakup, divorce (not in the right order)..all the aspects were carefully handled and nothing seemed excessive.
(4) fab music and naach-gaana(whats a bollywood movie without one..eh!)
the only negative being the movie has a poor start…thats what I felt 🙂
August 3, 2009 at 12:36 pm
Better stay away then .. I hd gr8 expectations after hvng watchd JWM n luved it and with the ratings 4/5 for this one @ so many places! Glad I read this review .. wil put the bucks to better use nw 🙂
August 3, 2009 at 5:40 pm
But I loved the smoking train engine and the railway platform scenes, the following of rikshaws … and disagreed with but enjoyed some of the discussions about love aaj kal 🙂
I also enjoyed the music and the three moments you have described…
August 3, 2009 at 5:51 pm
This is ‘why you met?’..sad cousin of JWM.
August 4, 2009 at 5:50 pm
Oh dear! I had read a really good review and had thought that it was worth it. Thank goodness for your review! Plan to steer clear of it now 🙂
August 4, 2009 at 6:15 pm
Good review. Deepika is really thanda and the girl cannot act!
August 4, 2009 at 7:34 pm
What a brilliant way of entwining ‘Love Story’ with ‘Love Aaj Kal’!
‘…yap yap yap…yackety yak…’ – LOL! I hear you! Both your agony and your anger.
I love the way you describe those moments. Ofcourse one of them had to be a Deepika one ;-)))
So, to summarise, this was a brilliant review. You ought to put this in print.
And if you have a registered fan club (here, or Twitter or FB..wherever), reserve the top place for me. Serious!
August 5, 2009 at 2:14 pm
it was saif and saif and saif all over. i wonder why he didnt do deepikas part too wearing a woman’s dress. he would have saved so much money and we would have been saved watching a wooden block on the screen
the movie is being apprecited by the young group whereas the somewhat older gereration are not in favour of the ending.
August 6, 2009 at 3:53 pm
lol 😀
So very well said!!! Wooden Deepika, ROFL 😀
August 7, 2009 at 12:13 pm
DIdn’t luck the movie..Imitiaz thinks that some ‘moments’ & decent songs make a good movie..don’t know about successful ..crappy script!!
August 7, 2009 at 12:15 pm
like *typo* although luck also falls in the same category 🙂
August 8, 2009 at 3:37 am
oh!kay!
that was some review 😀
been reading totally mixed reviews for this one
have to watch it and then read your review again 🙂
on a diff note(the Yap Yap Yap. Yackety Yak. Blah Blah Blah. Yada Yada Yada. reminded me of this 😀 )
though these are really good ones 🙂
have you seen these?
BEfore Sunrise
and
BEfore sunset?
lots of talking there too but oh boy! just how! 🙂
the kind one dreams of 🙂
August 8, 2009 at 10:28 am
QI? Here’s another blogger’s take on it..(a fabulos writer) 🙂 she seems to share your sentiments regarding the movie in a diff way me thinks 😀
http://www.withinandwithout.com/2009/08/film-love-aaj-kal/
August 9, 2009 at 1:34 am
I personally felt the movie was badly made but so loved ‘the Deepika moment’ too. It’s not like nothing could have been done with the story. I mean even half decent performances could have gone a long way to improve the movie. [Saif surprisingly was better as a Sardar than he was at being a cool new age dude].
The movie got a lot of mixed reviews but I guess it will make it’s money. I can see why lots of people wouldn’t like the film.
lol @ the whole Pritam inspiration bit. The music was fairly nice but yup the guy isn’t always original.
August 9, 2009 at 4:15 pm
oh well, what can I say. I liked it. Perhaps because I have not watched LWM and SNT. Expectations can kill a movie – looks like this movie was enjoyed by those who say it as a movie and not by those who saw it as an “Imtiaz Ali – of JWM and SNT fame” movie. The review was a good read.
August 10, 2009 at 7:31 pm
more than agree with you on the movie…..
August 11, 2009 at 4:36 pm
@Harsh: I think we should not expect too much….
@Bones: I was tempted to walk out, but managed to sit through the film!
@Sakhi: You’re right, he was more convincing as a sardar…. 🙂
@Ava: That’s the trick to enjoying most films… 🙂
@Reema: Yes, it is getting mixed reviews…many have liked the film.
@Kislay: Why did I watch it? I was stupid!
@Anita: It sucked big time….no comparison with JWM.
@Manish: Did you like the film?
@Rakesh: We both ended up watching crap!
@Balu: Did you watch it? It has got mixed reviews.
@Liju: I think your model makes the most sense!
@Kartikey: Haven’t seen that particular film, so can’t comment. But spare yourself and don’t watch this.
@Solilo: Sensible. Or you could watch it on my channel. Smirk. Smirk. 🙂
@OG: Why? You should have been enjoying your jargon filled conference!
@Sraikh: Waste of money, was it not?
@Ritu: He’s just wouldn’t stop talking…and with that voice, it’s torture!
August 11, 2009 at 4:59 pm
@Smita: You’re right, it was even worse than Socha Na Tha. But many people have loved the film!
@Preetischronicle: Glad you enjoyed the film! 🙂
@Swaram: Happy to have been of help! Seriously, save your money. 🙂
@IHM: But all that’s not enough to make a good film!
@Smitha: It has got mixed reviews…as you can see, many people here have liked it. But many haven’t!
@Shilpa: Welcome, and thanks. 🙂
@Pal: 🙂 Thanks….really appreciate the kind words. Not on either FB or Orkut, but I’m glad to have an appreciative reader here. 🙂
@anjugandhi: Welcome and thanks for the comment!
@Rahul: Well said…those things are not enough to make a good film!
@Indyeah: Thanks for the link…as for the films, I haven’t seen either, but will try and watch them..will let you know what I think! Did you watch LAK?
@Deepali: Welcome and thanks for the comment. The lack of a great story, coupled with indifferent performances, killed it. And why are you being so nice to Pritam? 🙂
@Spike: Welcome and thanks for the comment. Yes, expectations can kill a movie, and perhaps LAK is a victim of that syndrome. Not that it matters, as the film has done quite well.
@Pins and Ashes: Welcome and thanks! 🙂
August 12, 2009 at 8:49 pm
Yeah I agree Quirky Indian, I didn’t like the movie much, just liked some simple statements it made… blogged about it too 🙂
August 12, 2009 at 8:55 pm
nah! I am going tmrw to see it and keeping my fingers crossed 😀
August 12, 2009 at 9:00 pm
ah! I forgot! DO see those movies..
Before Sunrise
Before Sunset
(In that order) 😀
and THEN you can see ‘Waking Life’ (if you havent already)
I am betting that even if you dont love these three ,you wont hate em either
*fingers crossed*
August 14, 2009 at 3:44 am
horrible movie, completely agree..infact the bit about it being a saif monologue is so true….
August 16, 2009 at 3:08 am
I liked it. but nowhere close to JWM.
August 16, 2009 at 3:30 pm
@Quirky Indian
Did not watch it.. two of my friends watched it and hated it